The Curious Case of Natalia Grace

Beth Karas

Self - Legal Expert

Natalia Barnett

Self

Michael Barnett

Self - Natalia's adoptive father

Dan Cody

Michael Barnett

Cynthia Mans

Self - Natalia's Guardian

Cynthia Mans

Self - Caretaker

Caitlin McEachran

Kristine Barnett

Nicole DePaul

Self - Natalia's prospective adoptive parent

Kristine Barnett

Self

Jake Barnett

Self

Vince DePaul

Self - Natalia's prospective adoptive parent

Bishop Anton Mans

Self - Natalia's Guardian

Terrance Kinnard

Self - Attorney

Jackie Starbuck

Self - Deputy prosecuting attorney

Jackie Starbuck

Self - Deputy prosecuting attorney (Former)

Bob Cooper

Self - former police detective

Rachel Ambler

Self - Barnett's neighbor

Mark Nicholson

Self - Kristine Barnett's defense attorney

Mackenzie DePaul

Self - Natalia's prospective adoptive sister

Ava Schlegel

Natalia Grace